RGVII v Luck; Cast Your Loving Ballot

[Vince P]

Don't get me wrong, from what I've seen from his years at Stanford and in his short pro career, Andrew appears to be a guy of high character, intelligence and will be a great NFL Tackle football player. And for a white guy, he can run fast too.

However imo, RGVII is having a MUCH better year, at least statistically and should win Rookie of the Year (offensively) hands down. Not even a question. RGVII is probably one of the best rookie QBs I've ever seen and I saw Vince Ferragamo and Marc Bulger play when they were rookies too.

And Btw, RGVII is also a guy of fantastic character and intelligence, just like me.

Not taking anything away from Indy's exciting comebacks with Luck, but Vince will take a 104 rating that leads the NFL over a 74 rating that is about 30th in the league, any day of the week.

QB Beyers: http://espn.go.com/nfl/statistics/player/_/stat/passing

You make the decision, and cast your vote below:

A. [ ] RGVII
B. [ ] Luck
C. [ ] Dalton
D. [ ] Russell
E. [ ] Ponder

Vince P

[Fredo]

Luck wins it hands down.

[Triple Threat]

Clearly RG3

He has the best QB rating in the league, only thrown 4 INT's (Luck leads the league in INTs) and has played a tougher schedule

He has re-energized an entire city, and made the Redskins relevant again. He is easily the most liked person in DC right now and the only one that could get both sides to agree to a deal that would prevent the fiscal cliff .

[Theiman]

Clearly RG3

He has the best QB rating in the league, only thrown 4 INT's (Luck leads the league in INTs) and has played a tougher schedule

He has re-energized an entire city, and made the Redskins relevant again. He is easily the most liked person in DC right now and the only one that could get both sides to agree to a deal that would prevent the fiscal cliff <img src="/images/chat/lol.gif">.

Marion Barry Approves This Message

[Joel]

Luck wins it hands down.

Big surprise..Fredo chooses the white guy from the Midwest..

[Proro35]

Luck is going to win and it isnt going to be close.

[Fredo]

Luck wins it hands down.

Big surprise..Fredo chooses the white guy from the Midwest..

This coming from a guy who is Arizona sheriff Joe's Arpaio nephew. No congrats.

[Fredo]

JB hates anything East of SD. That includes anyone in the Midwest, Da Chicago Bears,The Fighting Irish ,the movie Hoosiers,The Natural,Brian's Song,Dick Butkus,Walter Payton.All farmers, any corn crop,wheat field ,the bread basket to the world. The John Deere company.Mark Twain,Huck Finn,the Big Ten,Mayor Daley. White Castles, Thin crust pizza from Vito and Nick's. Italian beef es.Arlington park, March Madness. Anytime he hears "God Bless America and amber waves of grain he starts screaming like a guy with turrets and says "Eff the US of A,California should start its own country you M effers"

[Kermit]

"...California should start its own country you M effers"

After Cal goes under and all the businesses go away, maybe they can work out something with Mexico....

[Joel]

JB hates anything East of SD. That includes anyone in the Midwest, Da Chicago Bears,The Fighting Irish ,the movie Hoosiers,The Natural,Brian's Song,Dick Butkus,Walter Payton.All farmers, any corn crop,wheat field ,the bread basket to the world. The John Deere company.Mark Twain,Huck Finn,the Big Ten,Mayor Daley. White Castles, Thin crust pizza from Vito and Nick's. Italian beef <img src="/images/chat/eating.gif">es.Arlington park, March Madness. Anytime he hears "God Bless America and amber waves of grain he starts screaming like a guy with turrets and says "Eff the US of A,California should start its own country you M effers"

Vito and Nick's thin crust pie wasn't bad..